How To Spend 24 Hours Exploring Ithaca, New York

Tucked away in the Finger Lakes region, Ithaca is one of New York State’s most underrated gems. Known for its stunning natural beauty, this vibrant city is a dream destination for outdoor lovers. With scenic state parks, dramatic gorges, and some of the most breathtaking waterfalls in the Northeast. But that’s just the beginning.

Downtown Ithaca is bursting with charm, offering an impressive food and drink scene filled with cozy cafes, lively bars, and locally loved restaurants. And while the Finger Lakes are famous for wine, the area is also recognized as one of the top cider regions in the country.

If Ithaca’s been on your radar (or even if it hasn’t yet), here’s how to spend the perfect 24 hours exploring everything this dynamic little city has to offer. Let’s dive in!

Where is Ithaca?

Ithaca, New York is located in Tompkins County in the heart of the Finger Lakes region. Nestled at the southern tip of Cayuga Lake—the longest of the Finger Lakes—Ithaca is known for its stunning natural beauty, with gorges, waterfalls, and lush forests all around. It’s approximately a four-hour drive from New York City and about an hour south of Syracuse, making it a scenic and accessible destination for nature lovers, foodies, and college-town explorers alike. Below, I will share some locations within a close enough radius to Ithaca, making for a perfect getaway option:

Stop 1: Breakfast at Milkstand Restaurant

Start your day in Ithaca with a delicious breakfast at Milkstand. This stylish, modern eatery is located just outside downtown at 215 N Meadow Street. Open daily from 8:00 AM to 3:30 PM, Milkstand offers an all-day breakfast and lunch menu that caters to a variety of tastes.

The restaurant’s chic interior, featuring marble tables, gold accents, and warm lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere perfect for a morning meal. Whether you’re starting your day with a sweet tooth or in the mood for something savory, Milkstand has you covered. From the indulgent brioche French toast to the flavorful chorizo scramble, there’s no shortage of delicious options. Plus, with a variety of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free dishes available, it’s a spot that truly offers something for everyone.

Stop 2: Sip Cider with a View at South Hill Cider

After fueling up, make your way to South Hill Cider, one of the Finger Lakes’ most beloved cideries. Just a short drive from downtown Ithaca, South Hill offers a peaceful, scenic escape with sweeping views of the Cayuga Lake Valley and surrounding orchards.

This charming cidery is known for its small-batch, estate-grown ciders crafted with care and intention. You can enjoy a glass on the patio, sample a curated tasting flight, or take part in a guided tasting experience. They offer multiple tasting options depending on your preferences, and the staff is always happy to share more about the apple varieties and cider-making process.

Stop 3: Chase Waterfalls at Buttermilk Falls State Park

Right down the road from South Hill Cider is the beautiful Buttermilk Falls State Park. The park’s namesake is a stunning 165-foot cascading waterfall that greets visitors near the lower entrance, easily accessible from the parking area.

For those eager to explore further, the Gorge Trail offers a moderately challenging hike. This 0.75-mile trail ascends approximately 450 feet, featuring numerous stone staircases and leading hikers past a series of waterfalls. The Rim Trail, on the opposite side of the gorge, allows for a scenic 1.5-mile loop that showcases the park’s diverse landscapes.

Stop 4: Explore The Commons

After immersing yourself in Ithaca’s natural beauty, head downtown to experience the vibrant energy of The Commons, a four-block pedestrian mall brimming with local charm. This bustling area is home to over 100 independently owned shops, boutiques, cafes, and restaurants, making it a perfect spot for leisurely exploration.

As you stroll through The Commons, here are some fantastic shops worth checking out:

• Autumn Leaves Used Books: A treasure trove for book lovers, offering a vast selection of used books across all genres, along with vinyl records and a cozy atmosphere
  
• Handwork: Ithaca’s cooperative craft store, featuring handmade items from local artisans, including pottery, textiles, and jewelry
  
• Home Green Home: A boutique dedicated to sustainable living, offering eco-friendly home goods, organic bedding, and green lifestyle products
  
• Bool’s Flower Shop: A family-owned florist known for its beautiful arrangements and selection of houseplants, perfect for bringing a piece of Ithaca home with you
  

Located just a short walk from The Commons, Dewitt Mall is another spot worth exploring. Not only is it a charming historic space, but it also houses a variety of independent shops and eateries. For example, you can browse the shelves at the beloved Buffalo Street Books, hunt for vintage treasures at Pastimes Antiques, or discover handcrafted goods at Fibers. Music lovers can stop by Ithaca Guitar Works, and The Cat’s Pajamas is a fun spot for quirky gifts and toys. For a bite to eat, enjoy a cozy meal at Café Dewitt or try the iconic Moosewood Restaurant, known for its pioneering vegetarian cuisine.

Stop 5: Check In at William Henry Miller Inn

By this time, you should be able to check into your accommodation for the night. For a charming and convenient stay, I highly recommend the William Henry Miller Inn. This beautiful Bed & Breakfast offers a perfect blend of historic elegance and modern comfort. Located just steps from downtown Ithaca, you’ll be within walking distance of The Commons, local restaurants, and scenic trails like Cascadilla Gorge.

The inn features nine uniquely decorated rooms, each with a private bathroom, air conditioning, and complimentary Wi-Fi. Guests are treated to breakfast each morning and delightful homemade desserts every afternoon. Additional amenities include free on-site parking, an electric vehicle charging station, and a cozy common area with a fireplace.

Stop 6: Have Lunch at Main Street Market

After settling in, take a short drive to the charming village of Trumansburg for lunch at Main Street Market. Located at 21 E Main Street, this cozy café and grocery store is a local favorite. They’re known for their commitment to fresh, organic, and locally sourced ingredients. Their all-day menu features a variety of options! You can expect hearty sandwiches, vibrant salads, and satisfying breakfast items like burritos and bowls. The market also offers a selection of local products. From fresh produce to artisanal goods, it’s a great spot to pick up some unique items to take home.

Stop 7: Visit Black Diamond Farm & Cider

Just a short drive from Main Street Market, Black Diamond Farm & Cider in Trumansburg is a must-visit for cider enthusiasts. This family-owned orchard boasts over 100 varieties of apples and pears! Many of which are rare heirlooms and European cultivars selected specifically for their cider-making qualities.

The farm’s tasting room, known as “The Cider Shack,” offers a welcoming atmosphere where visitors can enjoy cider flights and draft pours. Open seasonally from May through November, Wednesday to Sunday, 1 PM to 5 PM, the tasting room provides an opportunity to sample a range of orchard-based ciders crafted entirely from fruit grown on the farm.

Stop 8: Marvel at Ithaca Falls

As you return to downtown Ithaca, make a brief stop at Ithaca Falls. This is one of the city’s most impressive natural landmarks! Standing at 150 feet tall and 175 feet wide, this powerful waterfall is located on Fall Creek and is easily accessible. No strenuous hike is required, making it an ideal quick visit for all travelers. The falls are situated within a natural amphitheater formed by the erosion of shale gorge walls, offering a dramatic and picturesque setting. There’s a reason why the saying is “Ithaca is gorges!”

Stop 9: Dinner at The Rook

Cap off your day with dinner at The Rook, a beloved Ithaca eatery now located at 105 W. Court Street, at the corner of Court and Cayuga Streets. After eight years on West State Street, The Rook has found a new home in the Library Place building. Open Tuesday through Saturday from 4 to 9 PM, The Rook operates on a first-come, first-served basis.

The menu features elevated comfort food with a global twist, crafted under the guidance of Chef/Owner Gentry Morris. Signature dishes include the renowned duck fat fried chicken, an incredible pork schnitzel, and delicious arancini. Complement your meal with selections from their thoughtfully curated drink menu, which includes craft cocktails, regional wines, and local beers.

Stop 10: End Your Day with a Sweet Treat at Cayuga Lake Creamery

Conclude your 24 hours in Ithaca with a delightful stop at Cayuga Lake Creamery. Located inside the historic Dewitt Mall, just down the street. This charming spot is renowned for its small-batch, homemade ice cream. It’s crafted from high-quality ingredients sourced from local New York State farms. With over 200 flavors in rotation, you might find unique options or even some seasonal specialties. The creamery also offers a variety of sundaes and other treats like ice cream sandwiches and milkshakes.

Enjoy Your Time in Ithaca, New York

I hope this itinerary inspires you to plan your own adventure in Ithaca, New York! From its charming local shops and incredible food scene to the breathtaking beauty of its waterfalls and trails, this vibrant city has something for everyone. If you have any questions or want to share your own favorite spots, feel free to drop a comment below. Happy travels!